Propane Price Guide

Propane refill vs. exchange: which costs less?

For most people, refilling a 20 lb tank costs less than swapping it. Here's the math.

Refill

  • Fills a 20 lb tank to about 20 lb (4.7 gallons)
  • You pay by the gallon, only for what you add
  • U-Haul locations we checked on November 13 and 15, 2026 charged $3.15 to $5.80 per gallon, plus tax
  • Your tank must be in date and pass inspection

Exchange

  • Most exchange tanks hold about 15 lb (3.5 gallons)
  • You pay one flat price. U-Haul exchanges we checked were $19.95 to $39.95
  • At $24.95 that works out to about $7.05 per gallon
  • Fast, and it takes old or out-of-date tanks

The 15 pound catch

A "20 lb" tank can safely hold about 20 pounds of propane. It is already only 80% full at that point, which leaves room for the propane to expand. Blue Rhino says it fills its exchange tanks with 15 pounds. It cut the fill from 17 pounds to 15 in 2008 to keep prices from going up.

So an exchange gives you about a quarter less propane than a full refill. The label on the cage or tank usually says "15 lb" in small print.

A side-by-side example

RefillExchange
Propane you get20 lb (4.7 gal)15 lb (3.5 gal)
Price$4.25 / gal$24.95 flat
Total from empty$20.05$24.95
Cost per gallon$4.25$7.05

Example prices based on U-Haul prices we checked on November 13 and 15, 2026, before tax. Prices change by store and by week. See the prices we found. Use the calculator with your local prices.

When an exchange is the better pick

Where to refill

Places that refill by the gallon include U-Haul, Tractor Supply, many Ace Hardware stores, and local propane dealers. Walmart, Lowe's, and Home Depot offer exchanges only. See the store guides.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to refill or exchange a propane tank?

Refilling is usually cheaper. You pay only for the propane you add, and a refill fills a 20 lb tank to about 20 pounds. Most exchange tanks hold about 15 pounds for a flat price.

How much propane is in an exchange tank?

Blue Rhino says its exchange tanks hold 15 pounds of propane in a 20 lb tank. That is about 3.5 gallons. Most other exchange brands are labeled at about 15 pounds too.

How much does it cost to fill a 20 lb propane tank?

A full 20 lb tank holds about 4.7 gallons. At the U-Haul prices we checked ($3.15 to $5.80 per gallon), a refill from empty costs about $14.86 to $27.36 before tax.

When does an exchange make sense?

An exchange is a good choice if your tank is out of date, damaged, or won't pass inspection. It's also handy if no refill station is close by or open.

Do I lose the propane left in my tank when I exchange it?

Yes. When you exchange, you hand back whatever is left in your tank. When you refill, you only pay to top it off.

Page last updated .