Propane Price Guide

Propane refill prices in Indianapolis, IN

Refilling a propane tank in Indianapolis, IN costs $3.50 to $4.25 a gallon at the 6 U-Haul locations we checked on November 13, 2026. That's before tax.

Middle refill price $3.95 per gallon, plus tax
$3.50Lowest we found
$18.63To fill an empty 20 lb tank

Quick facts

Posted prices checked by hand on November 13, 2026.

Refill prices by location

LocationRefill / galExchange
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Southern PlazaIndianapolis$3.50–
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Keystone PlazaIndianapolis$3.50–
U-Haul Moving & Storage of EastgateIndianapolis$3.50–
U-Haul of LynhurstIndianapolis$3.95–
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Shadeland AveIndianapolis$3.95–
U-Haul Moving & Storage of EagledaleIndianapolis$4.25–

Source: U-Haul propane locations near Indianapolis, IN. Each location's page shows today's price and how many gallons it has on hand. How we check prices.

How this compares

For comparison, home delivery in Indiana averaged $2.75 a gallon this week. Refilling a small tank costs more per gallon than having a big home tank filled. See Indiana prices and history.

Refill or swap? Put these prices into the calculator to see what each option really costs.

Open the calculator

Other areas we checked

Albuquerque, NM$3.75 to $4.25 a gallonAtlanta and Marietta, GA$3.50 to $4.25 a gallonAustin, TX$3.60 to $4.25 a gallonBoise, ID$3.40 to $3.85 a gallonCharlotte, NC$4.15 to $4.95 a gallonChicago, IL$4.00 to $4.15 a gallonColumbus, OH$4.45 to $4.65 a gallonDallas and Garland, TX$3.75 to $5.00 a gallonDenver and Lakewood, CO$3.75 to $4.49 a gallonDetroit, MI$4.10 to $4.25 a gallonEl Paso, TX$4.15 to $4.65 a gallonFort Worth, TX$4.30 to $4.75 a gallon

Common questions

How much does it cost to refill a propane tank in Indianapolis, IN?

At the 6 U-Haul locations we checked on November 13, 2026, refills cost $3.50 to $4.25 a gallon before tax. Filling an empty 20 lb tank takes about 4.7 gallons, so about $16.51 to $20.05.

Where is the cheapest propane refill in Indianapolis, IN?

Of the locations we checked, U-Haul Moving & Storage of Southern Plaza in Indianapolis had the lowest posted price at $3.50 a gallon. Prices change, so check the location's page before you go.

Is it cheaper to refill or exchange a propane tank in Indianapolis, IN?

None of these locations listed an exchange price, so a refill is your main option here. A refill fills a 20 lb tank fuller, and you only pay for what you add.

Page last updated .